Florida School District Severs Ties with GOP’s James Fishback Over Misconduct Claims

In 2022, one of Florida’s largest school districts, Broward County, severed its relationship with James Fishback. This decision came in response to allegations of his inappropriate conduct concerning a minor student, Keinah Fort, who was 17 years old when the claims arose. At the time, Fishback was 27 and reportedly engaged in a secret romantic relationship with Fort while she worked for his organization, Incubate Debate.

Background on James Fishback and Incubate Debate

James Fishback founded Incubate Debate in 2019 to foster debate programs in middle and high schools across Florida. Under his leadership, the organization aimed to offer students a platform for developing debate skills. However, allegations about his behavior with students raised serious concerns.

• Fishback was accused of initiating a relationship with Fort in Spring 2022.
• They were said to have lived together and were briefly engaged after Fort turned 18.
• During their relationship, court records indicate that Fishback exhibited aggressive behavior.

Legal Proceedings and Allegations

In early 2024, Fort sought legal protection against Fishback, claiming harassment after their breakup. A judge ultimately dismissed her petition, stating that while the relationship may have been inappropriate, there was insufficient evidence of ongoing harassment.

Fishback denied the allegations, asserting that Fort’s claims are unfounded and stem from her personal issues. He emphasized his lack of criminal charges in his public statements.

School District’s Response to Allegations

The Broward County School District acted promptly upon learning of these allegations. An anonymous email from parent Aebony Moore led to the termination of Fishback’s volunteer work with the district. Moore highlighted concerns about the relationship between Fishback and Fort, identifying Fort as a minor in a leadership position at Incubate Debate.

• The district confirmed receiving reports of inappropriate conduct.
• Officials stated they had no prior relationship with Fishback’s organization, which he disputed.

Impact on Incubate Debate

The allegations troubled the advisory board of Incubate Debate, prompting one member, Nicole Castillo, to resign. Her resignation letter expressed alarm over the behavior purportedly witnessed and criticized the organization’s management.

This situation affected Incubate Debate’s operations, including the loss of venues for tournaments due to the allegations. Fishback acknowledged the scrutiny but maintained that he did not divulge the reasons for the lost venue, attributing it to false accusations against him.

Current Political Climate

As a newcomer in politics, Fishback’s entry into the 2026 gubernatorial race surprised many. He aligns himself with Governor Ron DeSantis’ agenda but has faced criticism for his rhetoric, especially toward his primary opponent, Rep. Byron Donalds. Fishback’s inflammatory comments included inappropriate references and controversial praise for fringe activists.

The political landscape in Florida remains contentious, with Donalds significantly out-funding Fishback. As the primary approaches, the ramifications of these allegations on Fishback’s campaign continue to unfold.

Community Reactions and Future Implications

The controversy surrounding Fishback has instigated discussions about the ethical standards in organizations working with minors. Stakeholders emphasize the importance of maintaining appropriate boundaries and safeguarding students’ welfare in educational settings.

With the 2026 gubernatorial race looming, the scrutiny over Fishback’s past conduct and its impact on his political aspirations remains a critical point of interest. Meanwhile, the Broward County School District’s decision to distance itself from Fishback reflects a broader commitment to protecting students from potential risks.