Dexter TV Franchise’s Biggest Plot Hole Ignored by Resurrection

When “Dexter: Resurrection” premiered, many fans hoped for resolution regarding a significant plot hole from “Dexter: New Blood.” However, the showrunner, Clyde Phillips, indicated there are no plans to address this issue in future seasons.

Key Characters and Their Role in the Plot

The unresolved plot hole revolves around Dexter Morgan’s stepchildren, Cody and Astor, and their half-brother, Harrison. Cody and Astor, Dexter’s stepchildren from his marriage to Rita Bennett, left Miami to live with their grandparents following Rita’s tragic death.

• During their time away, they still visited Dexter and their younger brother, Harrison.
• In “Dexter: New Blood,” Harrison reveals he spent years in Miami’s foster care system.

The Absence of Cody and Astor

This raises crucial questions about why Cody and Astor did not care for Harrison during his struggles. Their lack of involvement is particularly perplexing, considering they had previously shown affection for him.

In episode five of “Resurrection,” titled “Murder Horny,” there is a notable moment where Harrison and Dexter claim they are the only family left. This sentiment contradicts the earlier portrayal of Cody and Astor, who regarded Harrison as family and frequently expressed concern for him in the original series.

Significance of Family Ties

Cody and Astor are the last living relatives of both Dexter and Harrison, especially after the death of Debra Morgan. Their absence from the storyline leads to a significant emotional oversight, particularly in light of their previous relationships with Harrison.

• Showrunner Clyde Phillips stated, “In all honesty, we don’t even think about them.”
• This comment reflects a broader disregard for continuity within the series.

Fans’ Frustration and Narrative Choices

Many fans are frustrated by this oversight. A simple line of dialogue could have clarified the fate of Cody and Astor. Despite reviving various characters from the original series as ghosts, the omission of Cody and Astor seems puzzling.

This choice has led to disappointment among audiences eager for a more cohesive narrative that honors past character connections. As “Dexter: Resurrection” continues, fans are left questioning the direction the series is taking and the importance of family bonds in Dexter’s life.