‘Stranger Things’ Fans Urge Netflix for ‘The First Shadow’ Play Post-Finale Confusion

Fans of the popular series “Stranger Things” are expressing their desire for Netflix to stream the stage play “The First Shadow.” This play, currently running in London and New York City, features pivotal elements related to the show’s recently concluded finale.

Clamor for ‘The First Shadow’ Streaming

The finale, which aired on December 31, saw characters such as Eleven, portrayed by Millie Bobby Brown, and the Hawkins crew finally vanquish the villain Henry Creel, also known as Vecna, played by Jamie Campbell Bower. Fans noted that the finale included significant insights into the antagonist’s backstory, much of which resonates with viewers familiar with “The First Shadow.”

Backstory of Henry Creel

“The First Shadow,” a prequel that debuted in December 2023 on London’s West End and opened on Broadway in April 2025, dives into the formative years of Henry Creel. The play reveals how he acquired his powers in a Nevada cave, following exposure to material from the Abyss, and his subsequent involvement in Dr. Brenner’s supernatural experiments.

Key character arcs are explored in the play, including the high school days of Joyce, Hopper, and Bob, adding depth to their roles in the storyline.

Fans Express Confusion and Desire for Clarity

Following the finale, many fans took to social media to voice their confusion regarding the cave scene, particularly how it relates to “The First Shadow.” One user noted that the play explained Henry Creel’s mysterious disappearance in the cave and his subsequent transformation.

• One fan emphasized the need for wider access to the play: “It’s not fair to consider ‘The First Shadow’ canon unless it’s available for streaming.”
• Another pointed out: “Why should I go see a Broadway play to understand the show I’ve followed for a decade?”

Others remarked on the missed opportunity to incorporate the play’s content into the series finale. They hoped that additional context could have been provided to clarify Henry’s motivations and actions.

Current Performances and Success

“The First Shadow” is presently showcased at the Phoenix Theatre in London and the Marquis Theatre in New York City. Notably, the Broadway production achieved a record gross of $2,510,948 for the week ending December 28.

Fans were further excited when Jamie Campbell Bower made a surprise appearance at the Broadway show during the week, delighting the audience with a cameo as an older version of Henry.

For now, viewers can explore the making of the play through the documentary “Behind the Curtain: Stranger Things The First Shadow,” which is currently available for streaming on Netflix.