Evaluating Commanders’ 2024 NFL Draft Class After Two Tumultuous Seasons
The Washington Commanders have made a series of significant draft decisions in the past two years, evaluating the potential of their 2024 NFL Draft class. After enduring tumultuous seasons, the performance of these selections is now under scrutiny as expectations remain high.
Mike Sainristil: Cornerback Evaluation
Drafted in the second round as the 50th pick, Mike Sainristil from the Michigan Wolverines initially sparkled during his rookie season. However, a year later, questions surround his long-term role within the team.
With high hopes for the cornerback unit, which featured starters Trey Amos and Marshon Lattimore, Sainristil was repositioned from his college slot role. Unfortunately, his transition did not yield the expected results. Although he managed some interceptions, his physicality was frequently questioned, leading to vulnerability against opposing offenses.
- Year 1 Regrade: A+
- Year 2 Regrade: B+
While some improvement was noted when he returned to the outside position due to injuries among teammates, Sainristil must enhance his game to secure his future with the Commanders.
Johnny Newton: Defensive Line Struggles
Selected 36th overall in the second round, defensive lineman Johnny Newton from the Illinois Fighting Illini was perceived as a valuable draft steal. However, injuries hampered his contribution during the 2024 season.
Newton found himself primarily in pass-rushing scenarios, often sidelined behind established starters Javon Kinlaw and Daron Payne. His inability to handle run defense raised concerns within the organization, further complicating his situation.
- Year 1 Regrade: A
- Year 2 Regrade: C+
Although he showcased his potential with a three-sack game late in the season, Newton needs to elevate his overall play to retain his position on the roster.
Jayden Daniels: Quarterback Aspirations
In a more promising light, quarterback Jayden Daniels from LSU was chosen second overall in the first round. His rookie season demonstrated star potential, but a setback in 2025 paused his ascension.
Despite having improved protection and a stronger lineup, Daniels faced challenges that disrupted his rhythm. A series of injuries, including a hamstring strain and a dislocated elbow, forced the coaching staff to end his season early.
- Year 1 Regrade: A++
- Year 2 Regrade: A+
As the Commanders reflect on their choices, Daniels remains a beacon of hope. His determination to improve is palpable, especially as he witnesses emerging talents like Caleb Williams and Drake Maye succeed. The anticipation builds for his comeback, as doubt about his future seems unwarranted.
Conclusion
The Washington Commanders’ 2024 NFL Draft class faces mixed outcomes after turbulent seasons. With players like Sainristil and Newton needing to step up, and Daniels aiming to reclaim his remarkable trajectory, the organization will be watching closely as they enter the new season.
