Carl Cheffers Clarifies OT Interception Ruling in Bills vs. Broncos Game
In a pivotal AFC division-round game in Denver, the outcome turned dramatically in overtime. A pass from Bills quarterback Josh Allen intended for receiver Brandin Cooks resulted in an interception by Broncos cornerback Ja’Quan McMillian. This incident sparked a need for clarification from the officiating crew.
Carl Cheffers Explains the Ruling
Referee Carl Cheffers addressed the situation following the game. He spoke to reporter Jeff Legwold, offering insights into the ruling. Cheffers emphasized that “the receiver has to complete the process of a catch.” He noted that Cooks lost possession of the ball upon hitting the ground, thereby allowing McMillian to claim it as a completed catch.
The Replay Review Process
Cheffers indicated that their decision was confirmed by the replay process. However, the NFL’s official game log did not document a full review, suggesting that an expedited review was likely conducted. In this context, the ruling seemed appropriate. There was insufficient evidence to overturn the initial decision that Cooks did not maintain possession after falling.
Consistency in Rulings
Comparatively, this ruling raised eyebrows when juxtaposed with an earlier incident in Week 14. In that game, the ruling of an interception was reversed for Steelers quarterback Aaron Rodgers under similar circumstances. At that time, NFL Vice President of Instant Replay Mark Butterworth explained that Rodgers maintained control of the ball as he went to the ground.
- Cheffers’ Statement: Offensive players must complete the catch.
- Replay Confirmation: Ruling was affirmed but not fully reviewed.
- Week 14 Contrast: Different outcomes for similar situations.
This inconsistency highlights a critical issue within the NFL’s enforcement of its own rules. The league appeared to take two conflicting stances regarding whether possession was maintained during falls. The outcome of the Bills vs. Broncos game, therefore, not only affected the teams involved but called into question the consistency of officiating in the league.
Ultimately, this ruling significantly impacted the playoff landscape, allowing the Broncos to advance to the AFC Championship while the Bills were left to reconsider their approach for future games.
