Lindsey Halligan Resigns from DOJ After Unsuccessful Comey and James Cases
Lindsey Halligan has officially resigned from her role as an interim federal prosecutor in the Eastern District of Virginia. Her appointment came under President Trump but faced significant challenges due to her lack of prosecutorial experience.
Lindsey Halligan’s Background and Appointment
Halligan, who previously served as a personal attorney for Trump, was appointed to the post on September 21, 2025. This occurred a day after Erik Siebert, the former acting U.S. attorney, resigned amid pressure from Trump, who had called for criminal investigations into James Comey and New York Attorney General Letitia James.
Legal Challenges and Controversies
Halligan’s tenure was marred by court rulings that questioned the legality of her appointment. Federal judges determined she had no valid basis to assume the role of acting U.S. attorney, as her predecessor had already exhausted the allowable period for an acting prosecutor.
- Key Dates:
- September 21, 2025: Halligan appointed as interim U.S. attorney.
- Legal challenges commenced following her appointment.
- Legal Opinions:
- Judge David J. Novak asserted that filling the prosecutor’s position via appointment would contradict U.S. law.
- Judge Cameron McGowan Currie ruled Halligan’s appointment was unlawful, resulting in the dismissal of indictments against Comey and James.
In her brief period in office, Halligan secured criminal charges against both Comey and James. However, these cases were ultimately undermined by her contested status. Comey faced accusations related to false statements and obstruction, while James was charged with bank fraud and making false statements.
Responses to Halligan’s Resignation
Following her resignation, U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi commented that Halligan’s departure was a direct result of political opposition and legal hurdles imposed by Senate Democrats. Bondi expressed confidence that Halligan would continue to serve the nation in other capacities.
Conclusion and Implications
The Eastern District of Virginia, known for its influential legal figures, now faces a significant transition as it seeks a new U.S. attorney. Halligan’s brief and tumultuous tenure highlights the complexities of political appointees in the federal prosecutor’s office.
