Testing & Review of Madewell x Benjamin Talley Smith Denim
Madewell denim is well-known for its strong following, especially among fashion enthusiasts. Recently, the brand collaborated with acclaimed denim designer Benjamin Talley Smith to create a unique capsule collection. Smith, known for his work with prominent labels, designed this limited-edition line that features seven styles.
Madewell x Benjamin Talley Smith Collection Overview
The capsule collection includes a variety of denim styles priced between $88 and $398. Items available in this collection are:
- Mid-rise straight jeans
- Low-rise wide-leg jeans
- A denim jacket
- A classic sweatshirt
- An oversized sweatshirt
- A cropped tee
I had the chance to test two styles from this collection: the Coolidge and the Putney. The Coolidge is a low-rise wide-leg jean, while the Putney is a mid-rise straight jean. Both styles were assessed in light and dark washes.
Sizing and Fit Experience
For context, I typically wear a size 27 in most denim brands. However, my past experience with Madewell sizing has been inconsistent. I decided to try on both the Coolidge and the Putney in a size 27, hoping for improved fit consistency.
Here are my observations:
- The Coolidge fit snugly through the hips and thighs, sitting 1.5 inches below my hip bone.
- They can be worn cuffed or uncuffed, adding versatility to the style.
- The length is quite long; at five-foot-eight, I found them to skim the ground when cuffed.
On the other hand, the size 27 of the Putney was too constricting, making it nearly impossible to button comfortably. This fit issue suggests that sizing might be inconsistent even within this limited edition.
Design and Aesthetic
The Coolidge jeans stand out with their extreme wide-leg silhouette and deep-indigo wash. Designed with 100% cotton denim, they are intended to soften with wear while retaining their structure. This adds to their appeal, making them feel durable and high-quality.
Prices for this capsule collection are higher than typical Madewell offerings, with styles like the Coolidge and Putney retailing for $285. However, considering Smith’s expertise and the handcrafted nature of the collection, this price may be justified compared to other high-end brands.
Comparison with Other Brands
For those considering alternatives, mid-rise straight jeans from Abercrombie, Reformation, or Levi’s are praised for being equally stylish yet more affordable. For a refined cigarette style, the Madewell Longline Straight jeans receive high recommendations.
In conclusion, while the Madewell x Benjamin Talley Smith collaboration brings notable designs, personal fit and preference may lead some to explore other options. The unique silhouette and craftsmanship of these jeans are appealing but may not suit everyone’s body type.
