Safety Concerns Escalate in India and Israel: Who’s Truly Secure?
On a recent visit to Israel, Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi was warmly welcomed by Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu at Ben Gurion Airport. This meeting reflects the strong political ties between India and Israel, forged in part by Modi’s significant push for closer relations over the years. Their discussions are expected to yield several agreements aimed at further reinforcing this partnership.
Strengthening Bonds Between India and Israel
Modi’s visit marks a continuity of diplomatic engagement that began during his historic trip to Israel in 2017, the first by an Indian leader. Netanyahu expressed his sentiments during a reception at the Knesset, highlighting the “true friendship” shared between the two nations.
- Modi described the trip as a “historic visit.”
- Various agreements will be signed to deepen collaboration.
- Netanyahu referred to their relationship as a bond between “two ancient nations.”
Underlying Ideological Tensions
While these leaders celebrate their friendship, questions arise regarding the safety of various communities in both countries. In Israel, the ongoing conflict with Palestinians and claims of discrimination highlight insecurity. Amnesty International notes that Palestinian citizens of Israel, who constitute approximately 19% of the population, endure systemic inequalities and discrimination.
Furthermore, there are complexities surrounding the experiences of different Jewish groups within Israel. Historical injustices against Mizrahi and Ethiopian Jews showcase the structural racism present in Israeli society. Reports reveal staggering issues, such as significant poverty rates among Ethiopian Jews and historical kidnappings of Arab Jewish children.
Safety Concerns for Minorities in India
By contrast, India faces its own safety challenges rooted in discrimination against the Muslim population and caste-based discrimination affecting Dalit communities. Modi’s administration has been criticized for intensifying these divides, with a notable case being that of Rohith Vemula, a Dalit student who faced harassment leading to his tragic suicide in 2016.
The degree of caste discrimination is often underestimated, as evidenced by a 2021 Pew study indicating many Indians do not recognize its prevalence. However, emergency measures, such as the University Grants Commission’s regulations aimed at preventing caste-based discrimination, have faced significant resistance.
Shared Outcomes of Exclusion
The interactions between Modi and Netanyahu can be seen in the context of rising nationalism and the targeted policies that marginalize minorities in both nations. Critics argue that the leaders’ ideologies reinforce structural hierarchies based on ethnicity and religious identity.
- Both leaders tackle perceived threats to their majoritarian identities.
- Minorities in Israel and India face challenges to their safety and rights.
- Institutional discrimination persists against Palestinians and Indian Muslims.
The friendship between India and Israel is underpinned by complex socio-political realities that raise critical questions about who truly finds safety and security within these nations. Neither community appears to fully enjoy the security promised by their leaders, prompting a deeper examination of safety concerns in both India and Israel.
