Tomlin Questions Browns’ Decision to Trade Flacco to Bengals

Pittsburgh Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin has raised eyebrows following the Cleveland Browns’ decision to trade veteran quarterback Joe Flacco to the Cincinnati Bengals. In a recent press conference, Tomlin expressed his surprise at the move made by Browns general manager Andrew Berry, stating that it “doesn’t make sense” to relinquish a player who started the season as their number one quarterback.

Tomlin Questions Browns’ Move

Tomlin, known for his measured responses, found the trade particularly puzzling given the Cleveland franchise’s situation. The Browns, who traded Flacco and a 2026 sixth-round draft pick for a fifth-round selection, are now left with rookie quarterbacks Dillon Gabriel and Shedeur Sanders. Flacco, who is 40, had previously started the first four games for Cleveland after signing a one-year contract in the offseason.

Context of the Trade

The trade took place on October 7, shortly after the Steelers defeated the Browns 23-9, putting their record at 4-1. The Bengals welcomed Flacco to replace Jake Browning, who struggled since taking over for Joe Burrow, particularly in terms of turnover efficiency.

Analyses of Flacco’s Performance

• In his last outing with Cincinnati, Flacco threw for 219 yards, two touchdowns, and no interceptions against the Green Bay Packers.
• This marked Flacco’s best performance of the season, achieving a season-high QBR of 68.6.
• Tomlin acknowledged Flacco’s capabilities, emphasizing his experience and skill set as an anticipatory passer with strong arm accuracy.

Reactions from Steelers Players

Not all in Pittsburgh were taken aback by the trade. Former Brown and current Steeler Juan Thornhill admitted he wasn’t surprised, suggesting that Cleveland had moved on from Flacco after seeing him benched. Thornhill remarked, “They were kind of done with him,” reflecting on the typical trajectory of players once they are sidelined.

Tomlin has particular memories of the challenges Flacco posed in previous matchups. He recalled a game last season where Flacco stepped in for an injured quarterback and led a comeback against the Steelers.

Upcoming Challenges

As the Steelers prepare to face the Bengals in an upcoming primetime game, Tomlin stressed the importance of preparing for Flacco’s experience and skill. He noted the Bengals would benefit from increased timing and cohesion following their recent game.

While the Steelers focus on their game strategy, Tomlin’s critiques have sparked discussion about the implications of early-season trades within the division. The decision to trade a seasoned quarterback to a direct rival raises questions about organizational strategy and player management in the competitive AFC North.