Care Quality Commission CEO Resigns

Sir Julian Hartley, the Chief Executive of the Care Quality Commission (CQC), has resigned amid growing concerns regarding maternity care under his leadership. This decision follows the stillbirth of Asees, the daughter of Mandip Singh Matharoo and Amarjit Kaur, in January 2024. Investigations revealed that care issues may have contributed to her tragic loss.

Resignation Welcomed by Families

The families affected by the CQC’s oversight expressed relief at Hartley’s resignation. They questioned his appointment history, noting that his past leadership at Leeds Teaching Hospitals during a period of substandard maternity care should have raised significant concerns. A family spokesperson stated, “Mr. Hartley’s position at CQC was a scandal when staff have repeatedly reported unsafe care.”

• Families highlighted ongoing issues with care quality for years.
• Whistleblowers emphasized persistent complaints were ignored.
• Many felt Hartley’s role diminished trust in the CQC.

Concerns Over CQC’s Oversight

A statement from a collective of bereaved families underscored their lack of acceptance of Hartley’s apology. They described his tenure as a “scandal hiding in plain sight.” The families insisted it was their responsibility to expose the failings of the CQC in monitoring safety standards in Leeds.

In response, Hartley acknowledged the hardships faced by families. He expressed sorrow for the suffering experienced during his time at the CQC and pledged to assist in ongoing inquiries. He stated, “Families need transparency and answers.”

A Call for Change in Maternity Services

Professor Sir Mike Richards, chair of the CQC, acknowledged the significance of Hartley’s departure, labeling it a considerable loss while recognizing the potential damage his prior role could cause to public trust in the commission’s oversight of healthcare services.

A rapid review of maternity services across England is currently underway. This comes alongside a major investigation into maternity care linked to Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust, which is expected to report next summer. The ongoing inquiry into care in Leeds marks the fifth investigation into maternity services at a single NHS Trust since 2013.