Melbourne Cup: Experts Surprised as Winner Backs Defy Predictions
The 2025 Melbourne Cup has been a surprising event marked by the unexpected victory of Half Yours. Although this horse defied the predictions of most experts, it managed to take the title, highlighting the unpredictable nature of horse racing.
Experts’ Predictions and Reactions
Prior to the race, nearly 30 experts provided their insights and predictions. Only two individuals, Eddie McGuire from Nine and Danny Russell from The Age, correctly forecasted Half Yours as the winner. Despite this, many experts believed the horse would at least place well.
- Eleven experts predicted Half Yours would finish in either second or third place.
- The most favored contenders included Valiant King and Presage Nocturne.
Predictions Breakdown
The following list summarizes the expert tips leading up to the Melbourne Cup:
| Expert | Top Picks |
|---|---|
| Jim Cassidy | 1. Meydaan, 2. Onesmoothoperator, 3. Presage Nocturne |
| Darren Lockyer | 1. Al Riffa, 2. Absurde, 3. Valiant King |
| Michelle Payne | 1. Absurde, 2. Half Yours, 3. Flatten The Curve |
| Simon O’Donnell | 1. Valiant King, 2. Presage Nocturne, 3. Half Yours |
| Eddie McGuire | 1. Half Yours, 2. Goodie Two Shoes |
| Danny Russell | 1. Half Yours, 2. Torranzino |
The breakdown shows that while there was significant faith in other horses, Half Yours was largely underestimated. The surprising turn of events ignited discussions and analyses among fans and experts alike.
Additional Information
Following the race, fans are eager for the next events in the Spring Racing Carnival. Coverage is available through Racing.com, accessible on Kayo Sports.
The Melbourne Cup continues to be a highlight in the racing calendar, reflecting both the unpredictability and excitement of horse racing.
