Paul Finebaum: Historic College Football Program Has Lost Credibility

The release of the 2025 College Football Playoff (CFP) bracket has sparked significant debate among college football leaders. This year, the field has generated more controversy than the inaugural 12-team version last season. Notably, the focus remains on South Bend, as Miami secured the final at-large bid, edging out Notre Dame.

Notre Dame’s Controversy over CFP Selection

The Miami Hurricanes leapfrogged the Fighting Irish due to a combination of factors. A significant loss by BYU to Texas Tech in the Big 12 title game allowed Miami to clinch the spot. Ultimately, Miami’s head-to-head victory over Notre Dame emphasized the selection committee’s decision.

Notre Dame’s athletic director, Pete Bevacqua, expressed his frustration with the CFP selection process shortly after the bracket was unveiled. He conducted a media tour, including an appearance on the Dan Patrick Show, where he criticized the Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC) and the perceived unfair treatment of Notre Dame during the selection process.

Paul Finebaum’s Critique

ESPN analyst Paul Finebaum voiced his opinions regarding Bevacqua’s actions during a segment on First Take. Finebaum criticized Bevacqua for failing to substantiate his claims. He remarked, “Pete Bevacqua has said a lot of things; he hasn’t backed up anything.” His commentary pointed to a lack of decisive action from Notre Dame, suggesting that mere complaints without follow-through diminish the university’s credibility.

• Bevacqua’s comments lacked substantive action.
• Finebaum believes Notre Dame squandered opportunities throughout the season.
• The Fighting Irish have a single victory over a team in the final top-25 rankings.

Implications for Notre Dame

Finebaum highlighted the essential need for Notre Dame to earn their place in top-tier competitions. Missing out on a playoff spot reflects not only this year’s selection committee’s decision but also questions the program’s status and strategy. As Finebaum noted, a path to the national title game should not be viewed as a right, especially for teams not competing in a conference.

The situation underscores the heightened competitiveness in college football and serves as a reminder that a solid performance is crucial for playoff aspirations. Notre Dame’s struggles this season have raised questions about their future in an evolving landscape of college sports.