Christian Nationalism Sparks Conflict in Small Tennessee Town

In a small Tennessee town, a conflict has erupted over the rise of Christian nationalism, fueled by a planned development. Located in Gainesboro, Tennessee, real estate developer Josh Abbotoy is overseeing a project dubbed as an “affinity-based community.” This development aims to attract residents who share conservative Christian beliefs and traditional values.

Background of the Development

Abbotoy’s vision includes a neighborhood with residential lots centered around a working farm and a church. Initially, the project drew little attention until late 2024, when a local TV station aired controversial comments by two early residents. These individuals, Andrew Isker, a pastor from Minnesota, and C Jay Engel, a businessman from California, have identified themselves as “Christian nationalists.”

Contrasting Views on National Ideals

• Isker and Engel have questioned modern societal values, notably women’s voting rights and civil rights history.
• They advocate for significant immigration reform, suggesting mass deportations well beyond current policies.
• Some of their remarks included the slogan “Repeal the 20th Century.”

The local community reacted with alarm upon hearing these statements. Residents expressed concerns about the motivations and beliefs of the newcomers, fearing their extreme views could impact local governance.

Community Response and Resistance

Local residents have mobilized against what they perceive as an encroachment of extremist ideologies into their town. A resistance group formed, led by influential locals like Diana Mandli, who publicly stated that they want to protect their community from being associated with extremist ideologies. Mandli once displayed a message urging intolerant groups to stay away from local businesses.

Community members have voiced their dissent by attending gatherings where the developers were present and confronting them about their beliefs. Conversations revealed deeper fears about proposals such as “family voting,” where only one person per household would cast a vote, implicitly disenfranchising women.

Role of National Organizations

The situation in Gainesboro has attracted national attention, illustrating a broader struggle over governance in rural America. Abbotoy’s venture is seen as part of a larger conservative push, while residents believe they are fighting against organized attempts to influence local politics by external liberal groups.

This local controversy mirrors national political dynamics, especially as the political landscape in rural communities evolves. In the last election, rural voters demonstrated overwhelming support for Donald Trump, signaling potential shifts in local political affiliations and community values.

Future Developments

Abbotoy’s development is progressing, with infrastructure work underway and significant interest from potential residents. Many of these newcomers hail from states with opposing political views and seek communities that reflect their conservative ideals.

As the community of Gainesboro grapples with its identity amid changing demographics and values, the outcome remains uncertain. Both sides of this divide illustrate profound questions about representation, values, and the future direction of small-town America.