“Firm Refusal Echoes: A Resounding No”
Saturday Night Live (SNL) is known for its memorable impressions, yet some talents struggle to showcase their best work. James Austin Johnson, a prominent impressionist on SNL, has faced challenges with one particular impersonation. Despite his enthusiasm for the act, it has consistently been rejected due to its obscurity.
James Austin Johnson’s Challenge
During a Television Academy panel on June 2, 2025, Johnson shared his experience. He expressed a feeling of camaraderie with Fred Armisen, who revealed a similar predicament about his impersonation of Ira Glass, host of This American Life. Armisen’s impression never made it to the live show, as producers deemed Glass insufficiently famous.
At the panel, Johnson humorously echoed Armisen’s experience, stating, “I get that a lot at the table.” The “table” refers to a meeting where writers and cast discuss potential sketches. It was here that Johnson disclosed his own rejected impression of David Fricke, a longtime Rolling Stone editor and respected music journalist.
Audience Reaction
- James Austin Johnson attempted to impress the audience with his skill.
- His impression was met with laughter, though not in earnest appreciation.
- Johnson described his impression as his “best voice” despite the skepticism.
When prompted to perform, he characterized the voice as “the most boring” and demonstrated Fricke discussing Paul McCartney. The mockery he received was gentle, with colleagues finding humor in the effort rather than the result.
Despite repeated efforts, Johnson’s portrayal of Fricke has never made it past the SNL dress rehearsal. He lamented, “Every single time they’ve been like, ‘You gotta stop submitting that.’” The show’s producers maintain a tight schedule, leaving little room for what they perceive as niche humor.
Future of Saturday Night Live
As SNL prepares for its return in January after a winter hiatus, the dynamics within the cast continue to evolve. While Johnson’s ambition is evident, it remains to be seen if his dedication to highlight lesser-known figures will find a place in the fast-paced comedy landscape of SNL.
