Pirates Eye $66M Ex-Reds Star to Strengthen Pitching Rotation
The Pittsburgh Pirates are making significant efforts to enhance their lineup by targeting former Cincinnati Reds star Eugenio Suarez. With a history of struggling with power-hitting, the Pirates finished last in home runs during the 2025 season. To address this, the front office is actively seeking viable options to boost their offensive capabilities.
Pittsburgh Pirates Seek Power Bat
In their 2025 campaign, the Pirates hit only 117 home runs, ranking near the bottom in slugging and isolated power. Suarez, a free-agent third baseman, is drawing considerable interest due to his impressive performance, which included 49 home runs and 118 RBIs despite a .228 batting average. This kind of power hitter is exactly what Pittsburgh needs to revitalize their middle lineup.
Eugenio Suarez’s Potential Impact
- Age: 34 years old
- Height: 5-foot-11
- Weight: 213 pounds
- Career OPS at PNC Park: .882 over 65 games
Suarez’s ability to deliver power has proven effective at PNC Park, making him an attractive option for the Pirates. Adding him to the roster not only provides a veteran presence but also complements the developing talents of young players like Paul Skenes.
Possible Sign-and-Trade Scenario
One innovative idea being floated is a sign-and-trade arrangement. The Pirates could potentially sign Suarez to a three-year deal valued at around $63 million and then trade him to the Seattle Mariners for prospects or a controllable pitcher like Emerson Hancock. This method minimizes risk for both teams, particularly given Seattle’s familiarity with Suarez.
Benefits for Each Team
- Pirates: Acquiring a power bat to resolve their lack of slugging and provide mentorship to younger players.
- Mariners: Adding an established power hitter without a long-term commitment.
2025 Performance Overview
| Period | AB | HR | RBI | AVG | OBP | SLG | OPS |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pre-Deadline (ARI) | ~497 | 39 | ~100 | .250+ | .320+ | .600+ | .900+ |
| Post-Deadline (SEA) | ~91 | 10 | 18 | .220 | .305 | .593 | .898 |
| Full 2025 | 588 | 49 | 118 | .228 | .298 | .526 | .824 |
Evaluating the Risks
While Suarez brings substantial power, concerns exist regarding his strikeout rate and limited on-base value. Additionally, his defense at third base has been criticized. Furthermore, a projected $21 million annual salary could push the Pirates closer to their $125 million payroll limit unless they manage another contract.
Despite these risks, the need for offensive enhancement is clear. The potential acquisition of Eugenio Suarez could directly address the Pirates’ pressing concerns and help them make strides toward becoming a more competitive team in the league.
