Review: Rose Byrne and Kelli O’Hara Shine in ‘Fallen Angels’

In a vibrant revival of Noël Coward’s “Fallen Angels,” Kelli O’Hara and Rose Byrne deliver standout performances on Broadway, showcasing their comedic talents. This production marks the play’s first appearance on Broadway in seven decades, adding a layer of excitement to the theater scene.

Plot Overview

“Fallen Angels” centers around two affluent friends, Julia (O’Hara) and Jane (Byrne), who eagerly anticipate the arrival of their former lover, Maurice (Mark Consuelos). The women, whose husbands are away on a golf trip, indulge in cocktails while reminiscing about their past with Maurice.

A Night of Revelry

• Cocktail-Centric Dinner: The duo, fueled by champagne, navigates the complexities of reconnecting with Maurice.
• Comic Escalation: What begins as a fun reunion quickly devolves into a comedic exchange laden with drunken insults and accusations.
• Physical Comedy: O’Hara and Byrne’s chemistry enhances the humor, showcasing their skills in a slapstick environment.

Their antics, including Byrne’s heel removal to rappel down her chair and O’Hara’s unconventional strawberry dunking, inject buoyancy into the play, particularly in the second act. This scene stands out as a highlight, bringing much-needed energy to the performance.

Historical Context

Originally produced in 1925, “Fallen Angels” reflects Coward’s youthful attempt to infuse British theater with a French farcical flair. Despite its initial scandal, the themes of female desire and infidelity now come across as relatively tame compared to contemporary works.

Production Quality

Directed by Scott Ellis, this rendition of “Fallen Angels” embraces a screwball comedy style, reminiscent of the Jazz Age. However, while O’Hara and Byrne shine, the supporting cast’s performances, including Aasif Mandvi and Christopher Fitzgerald, fall flat. Consuelos’ portrayal of Maurice lacks depth, though Tracee Chimo’s vibrant maid adds a refreshing dynamic.

Set Design and Overall Impression

The elegant Art Deco set designed by David Rockwell enriches the overall aesthetic of the production. While the stage design elevates the play’s atmosphere, the narrative struggles to maintain consistent momentum throughout its 90 minutes.

Ultimately, “Fallen Angels” showcases Coward’s early comedic brilliance, yet it reveals itself as one of his lesser works. Although the play hints at the genius that would come later in his career, it lacks the emotional depth and sophisticated humor that characterize his most celebrated pieces.