Meg Stalter Starts July 6 with Barrett Foa and Ryo Kamibayashi

meg stalter begins her Broadway debut in Oh, Mary! on July 6 at the Lyceum Theatre, where the play has already set a box-office record. Barrett Foa and Ryo Kamibayashi join the company as the production keeps its current Broadway run moving into a new stretch.

Lyceum Theatre record

Oh, Mary! became the first show in the Lyceum Theatre's 121-year history to gross more than $1 million in a single week, a marker that puts the production in rare company before Stalter even steps onstage. The play premiered Off-Broadway at the Lucille Lortel Theatre in 2024, was extended three times, and then transferred to Broadway later that year.

The Broadway booking also gives the show an unusually long runway. Tickets are on sale through January 3, 2027, which keeps the production active well beyond this cast change and gives the Lyceum a stable draw heading into the fall and winter.

Barrett Foa and Ryo Kamibayashi

Barrett Foa will play Mary's Tutor, while Kamibayashi takes the role of Mary's Husband's Assistant. Kamibayashi's run ends September 13, while Stalter's continues through September 12, so the two performers will overlap by one day before the company shifts again.

Phillip James Brannon will continue as Mary's Husband through December 6, and Bianca Leigh will remain as Mary's Chaperone through that same date. Cheyenne Jackson is currently playing Mary's Teacher, and Tony Macht is currently playing Mary's Husband's Assistant until the new casting begins.

Maya Rudolph through July 5

Maya Rudolph is currently leading the title role through July 5, giving the production a direct handoff into Stalter's Broadway debut the next day. In 2025, the show won two Tony Awards: Cole Escola took Lead Actor in a Play, and Sam Pinkleton won Director of a Play.

That awards haul and the Lyceum's $1 million week explain why this cast refresh matters. Oh, Mary! is not a title fighting for attention; it is a Broadway property with proven demand, a visible award history, and a ticket window that now stretches to 2027.