All’s Fair Cast: Ryan Murphy’s Starry Legal Drama Brings a Powerhouse Lineup

Ryan Murphy’s new legal drama All’s Fair arrives with one of the most stacked ensembles of the fall, blending marquee names, scene-stealing TV veterans, and buzzy guest stars. Built around an elite, all-female divorce firm, the series leans on chemistry and charisma as much as case-of-the-week twists—and early episodes make clear the casting is the engine.

All’s Fair: Who’s in the main cast

The core team anchors the show’s tone: glamorous, razor-sharp, and unafraid to make enemies. Here’s the principal roster and what each brings to the table.

• Kim Kardashian — Allura Grant
  A high-powered divorce attorney and media magnet, Allura is the firm’s rainmaker: the closer, the brand, the lightning rod. Expect audacious strategies and headline-grabbing clients.

• Naomi Watts — Liberty Ronson
  The surgical strike to Allura’s shock-and-awe, Liberty is precise, polished, and lethal in depositions. She’s the partner who keeps the firm’s machine running.

• Niecy Nash-Betts — Emerald Greene
  Equal parts investigator, strategist, and fixer, Emerald reads witnesses like open books and often finds the missing piece that flips a case.

• Sarah Paulson — Carrington Lane
  A formidable rival whose rivalry with Allura is as personal as it is professional. When Carrington enters a courtroom, the temperature drops—and the stakes rise.

• Glenn Close — Dina Standish
  A legendary lioness of family law with ties to multiple players. Her presence hints at deep history and shifting loyalties inside the profession’s inner circle.

• Teyana Taylor — Milan
  An ambitious protégé who turns errands into intel. Milan’s arc tracks the cost—and seduction—of success inside a firm built on brinkmanship.

• Matthew Noszka — Chase Munroe
  Allura’s husband, whose relationship with the spotlight complicates home and office—especially when PR meets discovery.

Recurring players and the courtroom ecosystem

The show’s world extends far beyond the partners’ glass-box offices. A sampling of the recurring bench:

• Judith Light — Sheila Baskin, a high-net-worth client who tests Liberty’s limits.

• Ed O’Neill — Doug Standish, Dina’s partner in life, whose presence rattles old alliances.

• O-T Fagbenle — Dr. Reginald “Reggie” Ramirez, a steadying influence in Liberty’s personal orbit.

• Hari Nef — Maria Coulatis, a connector whose loyalties are never obvious.

• Grace Gummer, Steven Pasquale, James Remar, Michael Nouri, Kate Berlant, Jack Davenport and others rotate through as power brokers, exes, and expert witnesses who can tilt a case with a single line.

Guest stars making noise

Early chatter has zeroed in on splashy one-episode turns designed to spike the drama:

• Jessica Simpson — Lee-Ann: A cameo that doubles as a tone statement—playful, pointed, and self-aware—drawing fresh attention in the past 24 hours.

• Brooke Shields — Juliana Morse: A client whose public image clashes with private reality.

• Eddie Cibrian, Elizabeth Berkley Lauren, Rick Springfield, David Paymer, Kevin Connolly: A mix of familiar faces who slot neatly into the show’s luxe-but-cutthroat milieu.

Expect additional pop-in appearances throughout the season; this universe thrives on cameos that feel both flashy and narratively purposeful.

How the All’s Fair cast shapes the show’s identity

All’s Fair plays like a glossy chess match. The casting pairs big-swing personalities with actors who excel at micro-expressions—an arched brow here, a half-smile there—turning depositions into duel scenes. Watts and Paulson bring tensile precision; Nash-Betts supplies warmth and needle-point comic timing; Close arrives with gravitas that reframes every room she enters. Kardashian’s character is calibrated as a cultural disruptor inside the legal world, which lets the scripts explore how reputation becomes leverage.

The ensemble’s cross-currents matter. Rivalries aren’t just plot devices; they define aesthetic choices—lighting, wardrobe, even the cadence of courtroom dialogue. When Carrington faces off against Allura, the show shifts into a psychological thriller; when Emerald works an angle, it becomes a detective procedural in power heels.

Roles, relationships, and likely arcs to watch

• The founding-partners triangle (Allura–Liberty–Emerald): Expect fissures about strategy, ethics, and fame—especially when a case demands playing dirtier than the firm’s brand can publicly admit.

• Carrington vs. the firm: This feud is the series’ pressure cooker. Any settlement that looks easy probably isn’t.

• Dina’s shadow network: Close’s character hints at a larger map of favors owed and markers called in.

• Milan’s ascent: The protégé track is the emotional barometer—ambition vs. identity in a workplace where winning is everything.

New viewer cheat sheet: who’s who at a glance

the All’s Fair cast

This is a capital-S Star vehicle built around combustible matchups. The casting doesn’t just decorate All’s Fair—it defines its pace, its swagger, and its willingness to blur the line between tabloid spectacle and legal brinkmanship. With fresh guest turns surfacing and early episodes leaning into rivalries, the season’s question isn’t whether the ensemble can carry the show; it’s how far the writers will push them before the wins start costing more than they’re worth.