Thorold Cemetery Denies Muslim Burial for 18-Year-Old Niagara Woman

The family of Alina Masud, an 18-year-old student from Niagara, is facing a painful dilemma. After her tragic death in a car accident on December 3, 2023, they were informed that Lakeview Cemetery in Thorold, Ontario, would not permit her burial according to Muslim traditions. The imam, Asad Mahmood, who has been assisting the family, initially received approval from the cemetery’s director. However, just an hour before the scheduled burial, he was told that the Thorold council denied the request for a dedicated Muslim section.

Details Surrounding Alina Masud’s Funeral

Alina was involved in an accident on Highway 406. Her family wished for her burial in a section of Lakeview Cemetery specifically designed for Muslim practices. Imam Mahmood highlighted that it is essential for Muslim graves to face Mecca, Islam’s holiest city, which is a key belief in their burial customs.

City’s Response and Policies

The Lakeview Cemetery, established in 1886, is managed by the City of Thorold. In July 2023, city officials passed a motion to restrict grave sales to specific areas until those sections are fully allocated. A spokesperson for the city stated that their bylaws could not accommodate the family’s preference for a designated Muslim section. This decision has drawn significant criticism from community leaders and residents.

Community Reaction and Vigil

• Imam Asad Mahmood called for more consideration for the local Muslim community.
• A vigil is being organized outside City Hall in Thorold to advocate for Muslim burial rights.
• The Niagara Region Anti-Racism Association has labeled the city’s actions as a violation of human rights.

Local leaders, including Jeff Burch, MPP for Niagara Centre, have expressed their hope that Thorold council will work collaboratively with the Muslim community. Burch emphasized the necessity of respecting the burial rights of families like Alina’s.

Historical Context of Burial Rights in Thorold

Imam Mahmood has been making requests for a designated section for over two years. Initially, the city accepted these proposals and collected a $50,000 deposit. However, this agreement was later revoked on the grounds of avoiding segregation. Subsequently, the Muslim community has been forced to seek burial arrangements in Niagara Falls, where their requests have been welcomed. The imam argues that the denial of a designated burial area is a fundamental right for all communities.

Conclusion

This situation has raised urgent questions about inclusivity in public cemeteries and the need for municipalities to accommodate diverse religious practices. The community continues to advocate for equal rights to burial, stressing that respect for different traditions is a crucial aspect of any society.