Missouri Supreme Court Ousts Judge Thornhill from Bench
The Missouri Supreme Court has officially removed Judge Michael Thornhill from his position in St. Charles County. This decision, made on a Monday in a unanimous vote, stemmed from Thornhill’s inappropriate political comments during court sessions.
Reasons for Removal of Judge Thornhill
The court’s ruling emphasized Thornhill’s failure to maintain the necessary order and decorum expected from a judicial officer. Specifically, he was noted for:
- Making political statements about candidates and ballot issues.
- Wearing unconventional clothing, including attire reminiscent of Elvis Presley.
- Playing Elvis’s music in the courtroom and his chambers.
Background on Thornhill
Earlier this year, Judge Thornhill attracted nationwide attention after images of him dressed as Elvis Presley surfaced. This behavior contributed to the court’s decision regarding his conduct.
Initial Agreement and Subsequent Developments
Thornhill had initially consented to a six-month suspension without pay, which was to be followed by an 18-month return to the bench. However, Monday’s ruling required him to cease all judicial responsibilities immediately.
In November, Thornhill attempted to renegotiate his suspension, arguing that the extensive media coverage had irrevocably harmed his reputation. His legal team requested the court to reduce the suspension from six months to just 60 days, a proposal that was ultimately rejected.
Next Steps Following Thornhill’s Removal
With Judge Thornhill’s exit from the bench confirmed, Governor Mike Kehoe will be tasked with appointing his successor in the coming weeks. The process to find a new judge will be closely observed, given the attention surrounding the circumstances of Thornhill’s removal.
