Top Love Islanders by Most Reality Show Appearances Ranked
As the third season of Love Island: All Stars unfolds, fans are greeted with familiar faces. Several Islanders return for another opportunity at love, surprising viewers with their multiple appearances in the franchise.
Islanders with Remarkable Reality Show Appearances
This season marks significant returns, particularly that of Scott van-der-Sluis, who is now a four-time participant in the Love Island franchise. Samie Elishi has also made a comeback, signifying her third stint in the series.
Top Islanders with Multiple Appearances
Here’s a ranking of Islanders who have made three or more appearances:
- Casey O’Gorman
- Total Appearances: 4
- Editions: Love Island season 9 (2023), All Stars season 1 (2024), All Stars season 2 (2025), Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
- Casey first entered the villa in 2023 and has had various romantic connections, ultimately winning the second season of All Stars.
- Scott van-der-Sluis
- Total Appearances: 4
- Editions: Love Island season 10 (2023), Love Island USA season 5 (2023), Love Island Games season 1 (2023), All Stars season 3 (2026)
- Scott’s journey has been eventful, with notable connections during each appearance.
- Toby Aromolaran
- Total Appearances: 4
- Editions: Love Island season 7 (2021), Love Island Games season 1 (2023), All Stars season 1 (2024), All Stars season 2 (2025)
- Toby was a fan favorite in season seven but has yet to secure a win despite his multiple appearances.
- Gabby Allen
- Total Appearances: 3
- Editions: Love Island season 3 (2017), All Stars season 2 (2025), Love Island Games season 2 (2025)
- Gabby gained popularity in her first season, eventually winning the second season of All Stars.
- Georgia Steel
- Total Appearances: 3
- Editions: Love Island season 4 (2018), Love Island Games season 1 (2023), All Stars season 1 (2024)
- Georgia is remembered for her loyalty and has had significant connections throughout her appearances.
- Lucinda Strafford
- Total Appearances: 3
- Editions: Love Island season 7 (2021), Love Island Australia (2023), Love Island Games (2025)
- Lucinda’s international experience includes her strong showing in both the UK and Australian editions.
- Samie Elishi
- Total Appearances: 3
- Editions: Love Island season 9 (2023), All Stars season 2 (2025), All Stars season 3 (2026)
- Samie enters the Villa again, hoping to make her mark in this season of All Stars.
This season’s lineup showcases a mix of returning personalities eager for redemption and new beginnings. As the competition heats up, fans eagerly await to see who will emerge victorious in their quest for love.
