Ford’s Son-in-Law Claims Superior Belittled Him in Police Tribunal

Ernest “Dave” Haynes, a Toronto Police Services officer and son-in-law of Ontario Premier Doug Ford, is currently facing 12 charges under the Police Services Act. These charges include discreditable conduct, breach of confidence, and insubordination. The allegations stem from an investigation concerning a workplace email he sent, which is being adjudicated by the Toronto police’s disciplinary tribunal.

Charges Against Haynes

The charges filed against Haynes are serious in nature and are part of a broader investigation into his conduct. The incident that triggered the inquiry occurred on March 11, 2024, during a disciplinary interview conducted by a detective sergeant.

• 12 charges filed under the Police Services Act
• Allegations include:
  • Discreditable conduct
  • Breach of confidence
  • Insubordination

Email Controversy

The email in question was sent by Haynes in December 2023 to colleagues in Divisions 22 and 31. In it, he expressed concerns about low morale and various operational issues within the Toronto Police Service. This email led to an investigation initiated by his then-superior, Anthony Paoletta, now a superintendent.

During the disciplinary hearing, Haynes described feeling “belittled” and “embarrassed” by comments made during his interview, where the investigator criticized his email’s tone. Haynes’ attorney, Bath-Shéba van den Berg, argues that the charges are retaliatory actions aimed at silencing Haynes’ concerns about police operations.

Arguments in the Hearing

Van den Berg asserts that the disciplinary proceedings are frivolous and were commenced in bad faith following Haynes’ attempts to highlight significant issues within the department.

Conversely, the prosecution contends that the comments made during the interview did not constitute physical threats. They suggest that the remark about “ripping your face off” was not a real threat of violence but rather an expression of disapproval regarding Haynes’ criticisms.

Context of the Allegations

Adding further complexity, the couple has publicly fundraised to hire an external lawyer, indicating their determination to fight the charges. Both Haynes and his wife, Krista Ford-Haynes, have a significant social media presence, often discussing policing ethics and their grievances against the force.

• Krista recently tied Haynes’ complaints to the controversial Project South investigation, which implicated several officers in corruption.
• She argues that systemic issues within the TPS can lead to problems like inadequate supervision, which she believes contribute to broader issues of misconduct.

The hearing continues, with further testimonies expected. If the motion to dismiss the charges is not accepted, the tribunal will proceed to address the charges against Haynes in subsequent hearings.