Don Winslow Criticizes Andy Weir’s ‘Star Trek’ Comments

Prominent author Don Winslow has publicly rebuked sci-fi novelist Andy Weir over his remarks about the modern iterations of “Star Trek.” Winslow, known for his work on the novella that inspired the film “Crime 101,” responded on social media after Weir made comments during a podcast. Weir’s statements focused on Paramount’s management of the “Star Trek” franchise, which included a claim that a pitch he made was rejected by executive producer Alex Kurtzman.

Don Winslow’s Response

In a direct message to Weir, known for his bestselling novels “Project Hail Mary” and “The Martian,” Winslow praised his accomplishments while urging him to avoid disparaging other writers. He emphasized the importance of camaraderie among writers, stating, “Writers stand up for other writers.” Winslow also described Kurtzman as a “visionary writer, creator, producer,” insisting that Weir owes him an apology.

Background on Andy Weir’s Comments

Weir’s comments emerged on the Critical Drinker podcast, where he discussed modern science fiction. He quoted an analyst who suggested that contemporary sci-fi productions are heavily influenced by the original “Star Trek,” with the current series being an exception. He highlighted that he enjoys “Strange New Worlds” and found “Lower Decks” entertaining, but expressed disdain for the other recent “Star Trek” projects.

Criticism of Paramount’s Star Trek Management

• Weir described his experience after pitching a “Star Trek” show, noting:
  • Kurtzman was friendly during discussions.
  • He deemed the current shows “shit” due to the rejection of his pitch.
• Host Will Jordan suggested decanonizing “Star Trek” series since “Enterprise,” which prompted agreement from Weir, although he found it too harsh.

Winslow’s response reflects a significant concern in the writing community regarding mutual respect among authors. The ongoing discussion around the “Star Trek” franchise highlights the tension between creative aspirations and industry realities.

The Future of Star Trek

Currently, Kurtzman’s Special Hideout is driving the expansion of the “Star Trek” universe, with upcoming projects like “Starfleet Academy” set to conclude after its second season. Meanwhile, production on the final season of “Strange New Worlds” has also wrapped, leaving fans anticipating the outcomes of these series.

This exchange serves as a reminder of the intricate dynamics present within the entertainment industry and the importance of supporting fellow creators, even amid competition and rejection.