Senior MPs Question Keir Starmer’s Leadership Record as Prime Minister

During a recent liaison committee meeting, Prime Minister Keir Starmer faced pointed criticism from his own party members regarding his leadership record. One of the most notable challenges came from Cat Smith, a Labour MP representing a mainly rural constituency in Lancashire.

Criticism Over Inheritance Tax Policy

Smith raised concerns about the impending inheritance tax policy set to take effect in April. She claimed that this policy undermines family farms, compelling some farmers with terminal illnesses to consider hastening their deaths in order to transfer their farms before the tax takes effect. Smith argued that many Labour supporters feel misled by this decision, emphasizing the emotional toll on families.

• Policy change on inheritance tax begins in April.
• Smith described the situation as pulling “the rug from under family farms.”
• Some farmers are reportedly trying to expedite their own deaths to avoid the tax.

Despite the pressure from Smith and additional criticism from Liberal Democrat MP Alistair Carmichael, Starmer defended the policy without indicating any plans for a revision. His discomfort during the questioning was evident, highlighting a tense atmosphere within the committee.

Responses to Other Concerns

In response to queries regarding the ongoing strike involving resident doctors, Conservative MP Simon Hoare asked Starmer to rate his distress over the situation. Starmer rated his concern as “10 out of 10,” reflecting the gravity of the health care workforce’s dissatisfaction and the erosion of support for the British Medical Association.

Frustrations with Government Preparation

Committee chair Dame Meg Hillier probed Starmer about the government’s readiness to tackle pressing issues. Starmer shared his frustrations, citing numerous obstacles such as excessive consultations and regulations that hinder effective governance. He expressed concern over the slow pace of implementing necessary changes, which resonates with the electorate’s growing dissatisfaction with his leadership.

• Starmer cited “a thicket of reasons” responsible for government inaction.
• He lamented the impact of multiple regulations on his plans for reform.

With Starmer’s leadership record under scrutiny, both within Parliament and among the public, it is clear that these issues could significantly shape his party’s future prospects as they navigate complex political landscapes.