HDLC Staff Opposes Frostop Demolition for Tulane Dorms Construction
City planners and historic preservation experts have expressed opposition to the demolition of Ted’s Frostop, a diner that has served the New Orleans community since 1955. This decision comes as the diner faces possible demolition for new student housing aimed at Tulane University. The Historic District Landmarks Commission (HDLC) issued a report indicating that the diner, while not officially designated as a landmark, possesses significant cultural and architectural value.
Background on Ted’s Frostop
Ted’s Frostop is located on Calhoun Street, near the Tulane University campus. Since its founding in the 1950s, it has become a local landmark known for its iconic signage and community ties. The diner is particularly valued due to its long history and distinct mid-20th-century architecture, representing a rare example of drive-in commercial design.
Proposed Project Details
The owners, RCR Ventures, plan to replace Frostop and two adjacent structures with a three-story complex accommodating 39 student units, intended for approximately 160 Tulane students. A version of Ted’s Frostop is proposed to remain on the ground floor, incorporating its well-known signage into the new design.
- Location: Calhoun Street, New Orleans
- Original Opening: 1955
- Proposed Development: 39 student housing units
- Target Completion: Start of the 2027-28 academic year
Community Reactions and Historical Significance
Despite the developers’ intentions, the HDLC’s staff report highlights the diner’s importance to the community. Concerns have been raised about the impact of the demolition on local culture and character. The staff report emphasizes that the diner satisfies the criteria for architectural distinctiveness, even if it lacks formal landmark status.
Matthieu Robert, a representative of RCR Ventures, has emphasized their commitment to preserving the diner’s essence in the new development. “We have always included Ted’s Frostop as the anchor and essential part of the project,” he stated.
Regulatory Context
The HDLC’s recommendations, while significant, are not binding. The commission may still choose to approve the demolition, and the City Council could override any decisions made. Critics of the project fear that the community’s concerns may be overlooked in favor of development.
A spokesperson for Tulane University clarified that the school is not directly involved in the development. They will rent the new residential complex but do not own the property. This aligns with Tulane’s efforts to ensure that students live on campus for three years as part of a broader housing initiative.
Looking Ahead
The HDLC will review the matter in an upcoming meeting, and the developers anticipate starting demolition later this summer. If successful, the new project aims to enhance the housing options available to students while preserving community heritage—though opinions among local residents vary significantly.
