Ford F-150 Depreciation Split Favors Silverado in Higher-Spec Estimates
Buyers comparing the ford f-150 with the Chevrolet Silverado 1500 are getting two different five-year value stories. iSeeCars says the F-150 should lose 37.9% over five years, while the Silverado 1500 should lose 39.7%, but CarEdge reaches the opposite result.
The split comes down to what each data source assumes buyers pay. iSeeCars uses roughly $40,000 for both trucks, while CarEdge puts the average F-150 buyer around $62,000 and the average Silverado buyer around $58,000.
March 2026 Truck Prices
The comparison lands as new-truck prices keep climbing. The average new truck price in March 2026 was $65,964, up 2.8% from a year earlier, while the average new-vehicle price stood at $49,275. For shoppers deciding between two full-size pickups, the resale math now depends as much on trim and transaction price as on the badge.
CarEdge estimates a new Chevrolet Silverado will depreciate 43% after five years, while the Ford F-150 will lose 50% of its value on average over the same period. That puts the trucks on opposite sides of the comparison once higher-priced builds are part of the mix.
Ford F-150 Assumptions
For a base-model truck, the comparison favors the F-150 slightly, with the article saying it holds more of its value over five years. For higher-spec trucks, the Silverado becomes the stronger value-retention pick. The article says most buyers should find that a new Silverado holds more value than an equivalent F-150.
The estimates are averages drawn from older model years, so they are sensitive to the mix of trims behind the numbers. A shopper who moves up to a pricier configuration may see a different resale outcome than someone buying the least expensive version.
Chevrolet Silverado 1500 Trade-In
Condition at trade-in also affects long-term value, and the article points to basic upkeep as part of the equation. Cleaning the vehicle inside and out and repairing minor damage can increase resale value, which gives owners a practical step before they sell or trade.
That leaves the buyer with a simple but useful takeaway: compare the truck you actually plan to buy, not just the model name. The five-year depreciation gap shifts once the purchase price changes, and that is what turns the F-150 versus Silverado question into a trim-by-trim decision.
